I picked this book from the library because I thought I had heard something about it, but it turns out that I had read another of the author’s books a few years ago. I’m a little torn on this book – but I guess overall it was worth reading.
First, the story sort of borrows a gimmick from All You Need is Kill (Edge of Tomorrow), in that there is a way to control and change time. I love books that deal with time travel, and enjoy getting to learn all the rules. Even better, the author has created an entire world that is similar to reality, but diverts the timeline very early in an interesting way. How it diverts and when is one of the keys to understanding what is going on in this book – but you don’t absolutely have to notice it. Clever!
One of the themes of this book is what makes a legend – what is necessary to create an enduring symbol and what needs to happen for it do truly endure. It is a noble theme to examine, which makes it a little weird when the author includes some strangely graphic sex scenes here and there. Maybe we can blame Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarrow for steamy graphic fantasy – but it doesn’t really fit here.
There is a lot of complexity in the plot – enough that it takes quite a bit of explanation and iterations to spell it all out. On one hand I like the idea that it is turtles all the way down and things are happening on a deeper level than we first suspect. But on the other hand I think the author could have pared down the levels and made a tighter, evenly paced story. It felt like they wanted to be sure to tie up every single thing, and it felt like it had become a lot of work.
Again in this book most of it is written in the second-person perspective (haven’t I just read another book that tried this out). I guess there is a reason that the second person is not widely used – it is a little exhausting to read. Two characters alternate chapters making it sometimes difficult to remember who is talking and who they are talking about. You this, you that, and I’m confused.
It was a good attempt and sometimes quite entertaining, but I guess it could have been better.
Next I am reading The Peepshow by Kate Summerscale.