Books: Philomena by Martin Sixsmith

Apparently I got the wrong idea when reading the blurb for this book. I heard about this book in a (literally) random way – I’ve set one of my morning browser tabs to pop up a random Wikipedia page, and this book came up. It sounded interesting and they made a movie version with Judi Dench, my library had a copy available – everything aligned perfectly.

But the story was brought down by the writing skill of the author, whose dialogue recreations sounded like something out of the Hardy Boys. Although the story opens with one character (that I think was played by Judi Dench), 95% of the book is about Michael Hess. We learn about his struggles with being an orphan, figuring out his sexuality and identity, and the balancing act of being a closeted gay man and also chief counsel of the Republican Party.

All of that sounds interesting and it was, but I felt like I ordered pork and got chicken. I like them both but not what I was expecting.

There is a lot of info on Michael and his life, and I felt like it deserved a different book. I was invested in poor Philomena and we only got a few pages of her in the beginning and the end. It’s her name on the cover, right?

I feel like a different writer with a different approach could have made a much better book out of this.

Next I am reading The Things We Never Say by Elizabeth Strout.


Leave a Reply